In the basic game, there are a total of 6 screens for the game over. A random image will display when Baldi catches the Player before sending back to the menu screen; a blue fidget spinner, glasses case, pink scissors, telescope, and a music box.
There is a 1 in 99 chance that a small, orange rectangle with the number "99 " half-cropped away to look like a pair of eyeballs will appear after Baldi catches the player. After a couple of seconds, a jump scare will occur with the half cropped away 99 box now in a reddish hue appearing close to the screen along with loud distorted noises (called "ohno.wav" in the asset files). The game crashes after 5 seconds.
All of the objects seen in the game over screens are not dithered, unlike most of the rest of the game, except for the half cropped 99 box. A red fidget spinner jump scare. In Baldi's basics birthday bash, some screens, like the fidget spinner, glasses case, and music box, will rarely have a red jump scare function before causing the game to crash like the cropped 99 boxes, except with different audio.
In Baldi's basics full game demo, there is no screen for the game over, but instead, the game immediately brings back to the title screen.